Practice mode Critical Reasoning

Argument: “Every player in our team is an excellent individual player, so our team must be an excellent team.” Which best describes the flaw in this reasoning?

Correct answer C. It assumes that what is true of each member must be true of the group as a whole

Explanation

A team also depends on teamwork and coordination, so excellent individuals do not guarantee an excellent team. Moving from the parts to the whole in this way is the flaw.

Report a problem

Answer checked 11 October 2026 How we write and check questions

Tip: press A, B, C or D to answer, and N for the next question.

Argument: “Every player in our team is an excellent individual player, so our team must be an excellent team.” Which best describes the flaw in this reasoning?

Discussion

Have a question about this answer? Cancel reply

Argument: “Every player in our team is an excellent individual player, so our team must be an excellent team.” Which best describes the flaw in this reasoning?

More Critical Reasoning questions

Argument: Our coaching centre is the best in the city, because 90% of our students passed the entrance test. Which of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?

Argument: Brand X toothpaste reduces tooth decay, because people who use it visit the dentist less often. Which of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?

Argument: A company says its new fertiliser raised wheat yields, because farms using it produced 20% more wheat this year. Which of the following, if true, most strengthens the argument?

Argument: Since the new security guard was hired, thefts in the market have fallen, so the guard is responsible for the fall. Which of the following, if true, most weakens the argument?

Discussion

Have a question about this answer? Cancel reply